Radical Settler Envisions Jewish Takeover of Gaza
By Orla Guerin
WEST BANK — Who wouldn’t want a house on the beach? For some on Israel’s far-right, desirable beachfront now includes the sands of Gaza.
Just ask Daniella Weiss, 78, the grandmother of Israel’s settler movement, who says she already has a list of 500 families ready to move to Gaza immediately.
“I have friends in Tel Aviv,” she says, “so they say, ‘Don’t forget to keep for me a plot near the coast in Gaza,’ because it’s a beautiful, beautiful coast, beautiful golden sand”.
She tells them the plots on the coast are already booked.
Mrs Weiss heads a radical settler organization called Nachala, or homeland. For decades, she has been kickstarting Jewish settlements in the Israeli-occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem, on Palestinian land captured by Israel in the 1967 Middle East war.
Return to Gaza: A Dream of the Israeli Far-Right
Some in the settler movement have cherished the dream — or pipedream — of returning to Gaza since 2005, when Israel ordered a unilateral pullout, 21 settlements were dismantled and about 9,000 settlers were evacuated by the army. (Reporting from Gaza at the time, this reporter saw many who were literally dragged out.)
Many settlers saw all this as a betrayal by the state, and a strategic mistake.
Opinion polls suggest that most Israelis oppose resettling Gaza, and it is not government policy, but since the Hamas attacks on 7 October it is being talked about out loud — by some of the loudest and most extreme voices in Israel’s government.
The Controversial Vision of Daniella Weiss
Mrs Weiss proudly shows me a map of the West Bank with pink dots indicating Jewish settlements. The dots are scattered all over the map, eating away at land where Palestinians hope – or hoped – to build their state.
There are about 700,000 Jewish settlers in these areas now and settler numbers are rising fast.
The vast majority of the international community considers settlements illegal under international law, including the United Nations Security Council. Israel disputes this.
Controversial Comments on Ethnic Cleansing
We meet Daniella at her home in the West Bank settlement of Kedumim, where red-roofed houses are spread over hilltops and valleys. She’s in constant motion despite having an arm in plaster.
Her vision for the future of Gaza – now home to 2.3 million Palestinians, many of them starving – is that it will be Jewish.
“Gaza Arabs will not stay in the Gaza Strip,” she says. “Who will stay? Jews.”
She claims that Palestinians want to leave Gaza and that other countries should take them in – although in a lengthy interview, she rarely uses the word “Palestinian”.
Discussion on Returning to Gaza
There is no evidence that Palestinians want to leave their homeland – although many may now dream of escaping temporarily, to save their lives. For most Palestinians, there is no way out. The borders are tightly controlled by Israel and Egypt, and no foreign countries have offered refuge.
I put it to her that her comments sound like a plan for ethnic cleansing. She does not deny it.
“You can call it ethnic cleansing. I repeat again, the Arabs do not want, normal Arabs do not want to live in Gaza. If you want to call it cleansing, if you want to call it apartheid, you choose your definition. I choose the way to protect the state of Israel. “
Push for Resettlement in Gaza
A few days later, Daniella Weiss is selling the idea of a return to Gaza over cake and popcorn at a small gathering, hosted by another settler in their living room.
She has a projector, showing a new map of Gaza, complete with settlements, and leaflets entitled “Go back to Gaza”.
“People are asking me what the odds are this will happen?” she says.
“What were the odds back then when I came to these dark mountains and made it into this heaven?”
The handful in attendance seem already convinced. “I want to go back immediately,” says Sarah Manella. “When they call me, I will go back to Gush Katif [the former Israeli settlement bloc in Gaza].”
Controversy Surrounding the Gaza Conflict
Gaza is far from empty, but much of it has been erased after almost six months of relentless Israeli bombardment.
It is the “greatest open-air graveyard” in the world, in the words of the EU’s foreign policy chief, Josep Borrell.
More than 32,000 Palestinians have been killed, according to the Hamas-run health ministry in Gaza, most of them women and children. The World Health Organization regards the ministry’s data as credible.
Political Push for Resettlement
For some in the Israeli cabinet, the Palestinian territory – now drenched in blood – is ripe for resettlement. That includes Israel’s hard-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir – a settler himself.
In late January, he made his way through a packed conference hall, slowed by embraces and handshakes. He was among friends – about 1,000 ultranationalists pushing for a return to Gaza at the event entitled Settlement Brings Security.
Ben Gvir, who favours “encouraging emigration”, was among a dozen cabinet ministers in attendance.
“It’s time to go back home,” he said from the stage, to loud applause. “It’s time to return to the land of Israel. If we don’t want another 7 October, we need to return home and control the land.”
Family Life in the West Bank
In the shade of a sprawling tree, Yehuda Shimon is playing with his two young sons, who are in hammocks, hanging from the branches.
He has raised 10 children here in a settler outpost in the West Bank called Havat Gilad, or Gilad’s Farm, near the Palestinian city of Nablus.
All around him there are Palestinian villages, the nearest 500m away.
Settlers in the West Bank Dream of Returning to Gaza: A Controversial Quest
In a bold and controversial statement, Shimon, a resident of Gaza, claims a divine right to return to the land he once called home. “We must do it. It’s part of Israel area,” he declares passionately. “This is the land that God gave us, and you couldn’t go to God and tell him, ‘OK you gave me, and I gave to other people.’ No. I believe in the end we will go back to Gaza.”
But what does this mean for the Palestinians, I inquire? Shimon dismisses their concerns with a nonchalant wave, stating, “They have 52 other places to go in the world, 52 Muslim countries.” According to him, the new Gaza will be transformed into “another Tel Aviv.”
The rise of outposts like Shimon’s in the West Bank, coupled with the growth of larger settlements, is causing a sharp divide in Palestinian territory and escalating tensions. The UN reports a surge in settler attacks on Palestinians since October 7, condemning settlements as “an obstacle to peace.”
And now, settler organizations are eyeing Gaza once more. Is there a realistic chance of settlers reaching the beachfront in Gaza? A seasoned Israeli journalist dismisses the idea, stating, “Calls to resettle Gaza won’t be translated into policy.” But he leaves a chilling warning: “Famous last words.”
As the debate rages on, the quest of settlers to return to Gaza remains a contentious and divisive issue, with no clear resolution in sight.
